How can families understand therapy insurance coverage?
Below we outline a framework which includes a summary of insurance plans, descriptions of different types of services that are provided, key questions to ask prior to the first session of therapy, as well as how to explain insurance authorization to families and to prepare them for potential denial.
Start with who regulates the plan, not the benefit summary
While a summary of benefits (often included as marketing material for a health plan) outlines the copay for a behavioral health session, it does not explain how a particular behavioral health claim will be processed by the plan. The more important question is who wrote the rules for this particular plan and what protections are in place and how does one appeal a denied claim?
Four regulatory paths, four different conversations
| Plan type | Who sets the rules | Practical implication |
|---|---|---|
| Fully insured commercial | State insurance department plus federal parity law | State autism and behavioral health mandates apply, external review available through the state |
| Self-funded employer plan | The employer, under federal ERISA rules | State mandates generally do not apply, appeals run through the plan administrator |
| Medicaid or managed Medicaid | State Medicaid agency and contracted plans | Benefit scope is broad for children, but provider networks and authorization steps vary by contract |
| Military and federal programs | Federal program administrators | Separate demonstration rules, distinct documentation and reassessment schedules |
Families cannot even begin to ask about these categories. HR can tell you in one phone call which protections you have and how to appeal a denial.
Turn coverage language into a weekly and annual number
Consider how a family would spend their dollars in relation to their schedule (of work) and the units of service of care approved by your funding plan. Of work. Or dollars. Everything is traded in these three forms, and families should see them expressed in that light.
Work through the arithmetic with the family. Authorized hours times contracted rate times percent to be paid by insurance equals running total. Compare this to remaining deductible and out-of-pocket maximum. Families with high deductibles will spend lots of money in the early part of the year only to have insurance pay for them by the time the maximum is reached. Start dates and intensity of service can impact family members who work.
Variables that quietly change the total
-
Whether the deductible resets on the calendar year or the plan year
-
Whether supervision and assessment hours draw from the same authorization pool as direct service
-
Whether a separate behavioral health administrator handles claims under a different network
-
Whether caregiver training sessions are billed, and at what cost share
Match service format to both clinical need and billing reality
Center-based therapy, in-home therapy, school-based therapy and telehealth-delivered therapy are not equivalent when covered by insurance. Certain plans restrict the place of service for certain services, have maximum hours of in-home services, or require that a provider write a letter explaining the rationale for in-home vs. Another setting of service. Although clinical reasoning would dictate the type of service that a child would benefit from most, verification of coverage for these types of services needs to occur prior to the first session to avoid denied claims for place of service reasons. Rhode Island families weighing their options are usually best served by starting with a center that handles ABA therapy private insurance Providence billing directly, since the intake team can confirm place-of-service rules before a schedule is built.
Caregiver involvement as a billable and clinical component
Training for the caregivers of covered family members is a frequently underused benefit of child and adolescent therapy. Scheduling of such training in a deliberate fashion can support generalization of treatment findings between settings and develop a structured role for the family members of children with disabilities, as opposed to merely sitting in a waiting room and reading a book.
Give families a scripted set of questions
While an open-ended call to member services may get vague information, writing down all information given by member services on a list with space to record the representative’s name and member services reference number will help to get useful information.
-
Is this service covered as a medical benefit or a behavioral health benefit, and which administrator processes the claim?
-
What diagnosis and assessment documentation is required before authorization?
-
How many hours or units are typically authorized per period, and how long does review take?
-
What happens to coverage if the family changes employers or the plan year rolls over mid-authorization?
-
Is there a single-case agreement process if no in-network provider has availability?
Public search engines such as Google are limited in that they often list insurance provider directories, insurance company websites, and provider clinics. Families should instead refer to the family’s plan document and the back of their insurance card for specific cost information regarding ABA therapy.
Prepare for reauthorization before the first denial
Denials usually happen at the time of renewal. Work ahead of time and give the family adequate notice of reauthorization. Also, let them know that you will continue to provide services during the time of an appeal for up to the amount of time stated by the plan, as long as a written request is made within the time frame stipulated by the plan.
What to keep on file
Documents (e.g. Copies of letters authorizing services, denial letters that state the reason for denial, copies of clinical rationale(s) submitted to request services) can be as important as information when an appeal is necessary and a family understands what to expect when such administrative steps are required to continue services that are being provided and that the family likes.
